Context: Last night's episode of "What Would You Do?" a T.V. program that stages racism, religion bashing, etc. with hidden cameras to see how strangers react to taboo issues we still face.
This episode staged a young boy at a toy store with his father. The boy wants to get a Barbie doll and says he loves them. The "father" says things like, "Since when do you love Barbies?" loudly to get people to react. Immediately, in the first trial, a mother and son come over. The woman says to the boy actor, "There are a million good toys, why don't you pick something else?"
A second woman jokes, "It's probably because he
likes girls."
Actor dad: "Really?"
Woman 2: "Nah."
Actor dad: "Well if this was your son, what would you do?"
Woman 2: "I wouldn't get it. I would distract him with something else."
A third woman suggests a compromise, "They have a Ken."
A fourth woman enters and says, "I was a kindergarten teacher. Some kids go through a
stage where they like to do that."
Actor dad: "See I'm worried that he'll play with the doll now and, next thing you know, he'll start to wear, like, pink dresses."
Woman 4: "I don't think so."
In her interview (when the camera crews are revealed), the woman says children should be encouraged to explore whatever they want to do. Childhood is the time to do so.
Woman 5: "It's alright!" (that the child wants to play with a Barbie)
Woman 6: "I think you're making it into a bigger deal than it is. You'll probably buy it and he'll be done with it in a day. Unfortunately, what scares you [the child being gay], if it's there, it's there, and if it isn't, it isn't. I had a son who, when he was eleven, I was
positive he was gay. And now he's married. So, yes [to the boy], you can have the Barbie." In her interview: "I was bothered that the father was so upset about it. Whatever the child is going to be, he's going to be, so the father should let him be."
Woman 7 writes a note to the actor dad with the title of a book: "William's Doll" which is about a boy who wants a doll and whose father is dead set against it. Her interview: "There's absolutely nothing wrong with it. Just like a little girl should be able to play with trucks and anyone should be able to play with whatever they like."
[[No men spoke up during this experiment.]]
In the next experiment, the actor son wants to wear a princess dress. The actor dad in this case is completely okay with the child wearing the dress. An third actor man stages ridicule against the boy's choice of dress.
Woman 1's reaction: "It's none of your business. If my son wanted to dress like that I'd let him."
Woman 2: "I feel bad for your kids if you have this issue. If it doesn't affect you, why should you care?"
Actor man: "My kid could be going to school with his son."
Woman 2: "And it'd be good for your kids to learn a lesson from his son."
Woman 3: "You're a grownup and you're picking on him. I think you should stop."
Actor man: "What if he grows up and he still wants to wear that dress."
Woman 3: "And? What's your point? Actually, I don't care about your point because it's none of your business." Her interview: "I have children and I really care if people are being insulted or judged, especially in front of a child. I don't know why anyone would find wearing a dress upsetting. It's your life. Enjoy it how you want to."
Woman 4: "I think you're absurd and I don't think it's your business." [To the actor man.] Her interview: "Gender identity is up to an individual to feel. Maybe it will influence who they turn out to be, but who am I or who is anybody to choose that or stop it?"
Woman 5 congratulates the actor dad for what he's doing with his child.
About 2/3 of the women shoppers seemed to support gender equality when it comes to the child's choice of toy/dress. Only a few expressed fear that it might actually impact a child's gender identity. I was kind of bothered by the fact that NO men were shown reacting, but if this really is live television, so to speak, and the strangers were coming in on their own and reacting candidly, maybe the store didn't have many male shoppers that day. Either way, I appreciated the show bringing the issue of gender identity to the forefront via mainstream media.